Showing posts with label critique. Show all posts
Showing posts with label critique. Show all posts

Tuesday, 10 March 2020

A critical analysis of criticisms of Harry Potter

The Harry Potter series of books are either imbued with misogyny, racism and is written to promote the hegemony. Or it is a book steeped with antisexism, antiracism and is designed to bring down the hegemony, or at least aim a strong light at it.

The book cannot be all of those things at the same time. And whilst people are entitled to their own opinions, they must be able to support those opinions with good, cogent arguments.

Why could the book engender such radically different critical viewpoints?

One possible answer for this apparent dichotomy of opinions is ‘conformation bias.’

What is confirmation bias? In an article in Psychology Today Shahram Heshmat Ph.D. employs a thought experiment, which we can also employ. He asked readers to imagine themselves in a situation where they have attempted to reach a friend (a friend who they have an ambivalent relationship with) by phone and email, plus leaving messages, but they have failed to even acknowledge any of the messages or calls. 

In this type of situation, points out Heshmat, it is easy to fall into the trap of jumping to conclusions, by incorrectly using powers of reasoning, deduction and intuition to conclude that your friend is deliberately avoiding you.

There is a risk, notes Heshmat, that under these types of circumstances, you might start to react to this perceived slight as if it were factual, which may not be true.

Heshmat expands on his point by positing that confirmation bias occurs from “the direct influence of desire on beliefs.” Or to put it another way, when a person wishes that a belief or a concept is truthful, then the result is that they believe it to be true. The motivation, he feels, is their own wishful thinking.

This is problematic as it can result in the individual ceasing to gather further information on a topic when the evidence they collected so far confirms their prejudices or viewpoints.

This can result in someone embracing evidence that confirms their standpoint whilst ignoring or rejecting any evidence to the contrary.

Once we have formed a view, we embrace information that confirms that view, while ignoring, or rejecting, information that casts doubt on it.

Or as Heshmsat succinctly puts it: “Confirmation bias suggests that we don’t perceive circumstances objectively. We pick out those bits of data that make us feel good because they confirm our prejudices. Thus, we may become prisoners of our assumptions.”

The first text I am analysing is J. K. Rowling’s Harry Potter Novels, A Reader’s Guide written by Philip Nel.

The book is short, under 100 pages, but is very informative and makes interesting observations about the novels, about J. K. Rowling and about the motivations of J. K. Rowling for writing the novels and why she included certain features within the books.

The book is speculative in parts because it was written before the end of the series of Harry Potter novels, being published in 2001, whilst the last Harry Potter novel, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, was not published until 2007. However, it must be noted that the speculations of Nel with regards to the future novels in the series were, on the whole, quite accurate.

The book is broken down into five distinct sections. The Novelist, The Novels, Reviews of the Novels, The Performance of the Novels and Further Reading and Discussion Questions.

There are also a further two sections notes of the author and works cited within Nel’s work.

The first section covers the childhood of Rowling, how her parents love of reading had a deep and abiding influence on their daughter, and how Rowling’s love of telling stories was evident from a very early age, when at age six she was inventing stories and telling them to her younger sister Diane.

The book points out that even at the age of six after she wrote down one of these stories which was called Rabbit and featured characters like a friend of Rabbit’s who was a gigantic bee called Miss Bee, that Rowling wanted the book to be published.

The book also looks at how the friendship of Rowling and the neighbouring Potter family influenced her as she was growing up.

It is interesting to note that, according to Nel, the Rowling children (Jo and Di) used to play witches and wizard games with the Potter children Vickie and Ian. It is the belief of Vickie Potter that this had some influence on the fact that Rowling decided on the name Potter for the wizard hero of her series of books.

Nel explores the links between Rowling’s school days and that of Harry’s school, Hogwarts. One female teacher was used as the basis for Severus Snape, and another for Professor McGonagall, for example.

Nel explores the early literary influences on Rowling, citing authors such as Paul Gallico, Elizabeth Goudge, C. S. Lewis, E. Nesbit and Noel Streatfeild. Although later influence on Rowling also include Jane Austen.

Children who Rowling attended school with were included in her Harry Potter Novels, according to Nel. Including her best friend Sean Harris who was an inspiration for Ron Weasley.

Is there something of J.K. Rowling in Hermione Granger? Yes, though modestly Rowling claims she was nowhere near as clever as Hermione!

Nel indicates Rowling is a lover of witticisms and puns, play on word, satire and parody, which she employs in her novels with some skill.

For example, the familial residence of Sirius Black and his antecedents is Number 12 Grimmauld Place, a punning play on words.

Nel also shows Rowling’s use of humour and puzzles extends to mathematics and that the book is full of prime number references and jokes.

Nel also references the fact that Rowling’s magicians are 18th or early 19th century in the way  they communicate by letter (never email!) though his cousin Dudley does have what other boys of the 1990s had, TV, computer, PlayStation, etc.

Nel believes the books show the hallmarks of having been written by a social activist. It depicts contemporary British society viewed through the lens of magic, touching on the hegemony, corruption, class struggles, racism, slavery and exploitation. 

Rowling spent some time working for Amnesty International researching human rights abuses in Francophone Africa. Nel muses this might be the basis for the gentle parody in Hermione’s Society for the promotion of Elfish Welfare or SPEW.  Was this a satire on the youthful political activism of Rowling? Nel believes so.

Although not a hagiography, Nel’s book is a short, though complete look at the Harry Potter phenomena which opens the reader to exploring this subject in more depth by way of the Further Reading and Discussion Questions section, the authors’ notes and the Works Cited section.

The second book I am examining is Harry Potter’s World, Multidisciplinary Critical Perspectives edited by Elizabeth E. Heilman.

The book is as the title implies, a multidisciplinary examination of the Harry Potter novels.
Whilst the book’s approach is interesting, it must be pointed out that there appears to be problems with the critical analyses of several of the authors. Whilst some of the authors seem to grasp the Harry Potter phenomena, others do not.

Hollie Anderson author of the chapter: “Reading Harry Potter with Navajo Eyes” is a special example of this depth of understanding because of her membership of the Navajo race. Not only is this because the Navajo people understand and appreciate the use of magic, Navajo people, as Anderson indicates, understand the concept of being sent away to boarding school, something the vast majority of American readers of Harry Potter would have no concept of.

Anderson also indicates she has a sympathetic reading of the struggles of wizards from Muggle families such as Hermione, because wizards and witches from Muggle families are often looked down on by some Pureblood wizarding families.

Anderson also shows sympathy for trainee wizards like Neville Longbottom who, she indicates, is a member of a pureblood wizarding family yet who seems to have considerable difficulties in safely employing his wizarding abilities.

Unfortunately the weakest chapter in the book is that by Elizabeth E. Heilman herself, Blue Wizards and Pink Wizards.

Heilman takes issue with some of the character names that Rowling chose. Heilman states (page 234) that: “Neville sounds like snivel.”

One could presume that Neville Cardus, Neville Chamberlain and Neville "Noddy" Holder of Slade (amongst other famous Nevilles) might raise objections to this characterisation of a perfectly ordinary British name as “sounding like snivel!”

Neville Longbottom is, one might argue, a quintessentially British name and that this suits the character of Neville Longbottom because he is a quintessentially British character. Clumsy, prone to get things wrong but always there to back the right side when it came down to it.

It can be argued that the name Neville Longbottom was chosen also because it is one of those old British names that sounds slightly amusing (Longbottom, Winterbottom, etc) and not because it has an (imagined) similarity to snivel.

It might be significant that Neville is one of the least popular boys’ names with only 1,081 people bearing the name in the entire USA, with the percentage frequency being .4%.

There is a great deal of humour in the Harry Potter books, but it is mainly gentle sarcasm and parody. Perhaps the British humour of Rowling did not translate well to American academics?

The books seem to be a parody of the British novels for children read by children who grew up to be of the generation that Rowling is a part of.

The vast majority of children who read and enjoyed books about children at boarding school were not, generally, children who attended boarding school or, indeed, knew anyone who attended boarding school. These would include The Chalet School series of novels for girls and the Jennings series of books for boys.

Heilman is critical of the portrayal of girls and boys, taking issue with the depiction that girls giggle and gossip and tend to cry sometimes and that boys will, at least, make the attempt at appearing to be manly.

From my memory this was the reality of existence when I was a teenager growing up in a semi-rural English community much like Rowling had grown up in; the girls did tend to giggle and gossip, we boys did make the attempt to appear to be manly. Or as well as we could manage!

I can’t help but wonder if some of the ‘problems’ that American academics like Heilman have perceived within the Harry Potter novels might be that the books were written by a British woman for her pleasure and aimed at being read by other British people for their pleasure? All of whom share at least some parts of a common British heritage.

In pretty much the same way that Americans all have parts of a common American heritage. For example American children of all races, creeds and ages would understand a children’s book that featured the Superbowl or made copious references to the World Series.  But most British children wouldn’t have a clue what this was referencing.

There is a further problem with Heilman’s analysis. Rowling has imagined a world that is, like the world we live in, an imperfect society with injustice and evil with attempts to mitigate the effects of injustice and evil.

Rowling’s novels in the Harry Potter series reports on these imperfections and how the characters within them attempt to correct the injustices and to defeat evil.

Heilman in her analysis of the novels seems to form the view that Rowling actually believes that the injustices and imperfections she has depicted are acceptable, which is a logical leap that would be akin to a reviewer believing that because Agatha Christie wrote about murders that she somehow thought murder was acceptable.

One can’t help but wonder if some critics of Rowling and her Harry Potter novels have committed the error of viewing them through the lens of their own cultural hegemony?

References:-
Nel, P., 2001. J. K. Rowling's Harry Potter Novels. 1st ed. New York: Continuum.
Heilman, E., 2003. Harry Potter's World. 1st ed. New York: RoutledgeFalmer.
Shahram Heshmat Ph.D.. 2015. Psychology Today. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/science-choice/201504/what-is-confirmation-bias. [Accessed 14 May 2018].
https://names.mongabay.com/male_names9.htm. 2006. Uncommon guy names in the United States. [ONLINE] Available at: https://names.mongabay.com/male_names9.htm. [Accessed 11 May 2018].

Sunday, 17 July 2011

An article and a critique of that article

Do you remember a time when the streets in your town, village or suburb town were kept clean? When there were enough street lights to keep the streets well-lit and safe for women to walk along alone? When flooding was not caused in heavy rain because drains were cleaned on a weekly basis?

When roads were properly surfaced? When pavements were well maintained? Do you remember when public buildings were looked after properly? When there were enough trains to satisfy public demands? When buses were cheap and plentiful? If you do, then you are probably over 40.

Because prior to 1974, that is by-and-large, what happened in the vast majority of our towns, cities and villages. that has been the fate of many urban areas since 1974?

The advent of the Heathite 1974 Local Government Act. This act put an end to the urban district councils and the rural district councils that had served Britain so well since their creation in the late 19th century.

Whilst it may have been true that the system could have benefited from some minor adjustments (due to changing demographics) the truth was that the changes enacted by the 1974 Local Government Act were driven not by a desire to reform but by a narrow-minded wish to drive through ideological changes.

One must remember that, especially in the 1970s, the political scene in the United Kingdom was beset by the economic theory that: “Big was Beautiful” and that “Big was Best.”

The term “Economies of Scale” was bandied about with something that used to be called “gay abandon.” People would try to look as if they knew what they were talking about and say: “Economies of scale. That’s what it is all about. We must put an end to small and inefficient local government units. Instead, we must introduce large and efficient units of local government.”

Were the previous smaller urban and rural district councils really all that inefficient? In the small, but busy market town in which I lived, prior to 1974 if a resident of a council house had a problem with the house, all they had to do was ‘phone up the office, or pop into town and visit the office.

A person who had been a resident of a council house for many years said: “It was really simple. We just went to the office, told someone there what the problem was and they would say: “The lads are out on a job at the moment. I’ll tell them what you need doing as soon as they come back.” Chances were that the job would be
done later that day or early the next morning.”

“What happened when the 1974 Local Government Act was put into force?”

“Oh, that was a nightmare! They centralised all the housing workers in an office ten miles away. If you wanted a job done, you had to phone them up and tell some kid there that you had a problem. They were supposed to tell the repair team to get the job done.

“But usually, nothing happened, so you had to keep calling time after time after time. It became a real nightmare! From getting a job done in a matter of a day or so, it became so bad that sometimes even a very simple job would take them up to a year to do.”

I remember speaking to a manager at the district council housing department. He suddenly, in the middle of the office, lost his temper in a very spectacular way.

“I am sick to death of this bloody department! I am especially sick to death of these lying, conniving little bitches that work here! Well, work is too strong a word for what they do! All they do is answer calls; lie to people when they ask for repairs to be done! They never bother to tell anyone about the calls that they take! They never bother themselves to fill out work report cards, so as a consequence of their bone idleness, the repairs are never done! And of course, because they never give their names to the callers, the poor sods don’t have a clue who they spoke to, so they can’t make a complaint!”

He then turned to some stunned looking member of staff who was carrying a folder and shouted: “And walking round carrying a folder stuffed full of old paperwork might impress some people, but it doesn’t impress ME!”

In quieter tones he said to me: “It never used to be like this when I worked for one of the smaller urban authorities. Everyone knew every one of the clients we had, so they built up a rapport with them. But now, well, there are hundreds of staff and thousands of clients, so the incentive to actually give a damn has gone.

“Most of the staff here just turn up for their wages, they don’t care about the ethos of public service. It’s not a concept many of them are familiar with. I am only talking like this because I am so sick of working with this bunch of deadbeats that I am taking early retirement. I am finishing later this week and I have wanted this shower to know what I have thought of them for several years.”

Up until 1974 the local urban authority (controlled by a comfortable alliance between Conservatives and some fiercely independent independents) had collected and recycled waste paper and had ensured that the streets were properly swept every day, and that each drain in every street was cleaned out every week by a large road sweeping machine.

By 1976 this drain cleaning had been reduced to once a fortnight. Then it was still further reduced to once a month. I can’t for the life of me recall exactly when the district council decided to completely stop the cleaning out of drains, but stop this vital service they certainly did.

Of course, without any cleaning out of any kind, the drains began to silt up. Some drains in the area are so badly silted up that plants and even in one drain a small shrub have began to grow. Or perhaps it would be more accurate to describe it as a former drain?

This has caused much flooding of parts of the area, which have never experienced flooding before. And the pantomime show of council members and officers wringing their hands and crying out: “Oh, dear! How can these floods during times of heavy rain ever have started to occur?” is amusing, in a sort of “Dick Whittington meets Kafka” sort of a way. Unless your home is one that has suffered from flooding as a result.

And there are in the area pavements that have not been resurfaced since the early 1970s. Just think about that for a moment. There have been the last few moon landings, shuttlecraft launches and disasters, The Falklands war, two wars in Iraq, at least six different prime ministers and in that 30 plus years, some pavements in some
of our towns haven’t even been re-surfaced once.

But in the name of all that is good, why? Why is this the case? Because the 1974 Local Government Act created large behemoth ‘non-local’ authorities that were so divorced from the areas that they were supposed to serve that they never bothered to do the simple things. Such as clean drains, sweep streets, look after street lights and maintain pavements. It almost seems as if there came into being a culture of indifference to the squalor that their policies created and a calculated, cruel indifference to the lives of the electorate.

The indifference was brought home to me in the early 1980s, some six or so years after the creation of the megalithic authority that had replaced the former urban and rural district councils. The council had, due it must be said to the ineptitude of its own officials, made a complete mess of the rent payments of a disabled man who was in his mid 90s. The statement that was made to the press said: “We are aware that there are some problems with this rent account. If Mr Bloggs would like to come to the housing offices, we will explain the situation to him.”

How –or why- they expected an elderly man who was totally disabled to make a 25 mile round trip by a non-existent public transport service, so they could explain their mistakes to him was never made clear. But it did bring home to me the fact that the area the council covered was so vast that it seemed unable to effectively provide the services that the residents of the area have paid for through their very expensive rate bills.

Just after the enactment of the 1974 Local Government Act there was a cynical joke doing the rounds that did sum up one of the problems that we are still feeling the effects of: “What is the difference between a Clerk of works and a director of operational services? - About five times the salary.”

The gravy train that was set in motion has sapped a great deal of the resources that should have been available for basic core services. Such as cleaning drains, maintaining roads, resurfacing pavements and looking after housing.

The critique of the article

Writing this article proved not to be quite so easy a task as I had at first thought. Whilst the concepts are fresh in my mind –after all, I had experienced them at first hand, as it where, whilst trying to look at the various drafts from several differing points of view, I began to become aware that I needed to understand that not everyone who would read the article had lived through the events that I had described.

I therefore had to examine the article and to remove some items and words and also to explain some points in ways that I hoped would be clearer. Ways in which I hoped to be able to help the younger reader who had not been born in the late 1950s as I had, to understand that, for example, road drains were cleaned out every week (as a matter of course, not just because they were blocked) and streets swept clean on a regular basis.

I also detected a hint towards the hyperbolic in my writing. Perhaps using three long words when one shorter word would have served my purposes equally well. In fact, would probably have served my purposes much better.

It is all too easy, I now realise, to lose one’s reader in a sea of over exuberant writing, meaning that the point or points one is trying to get across and to explain are lost to the reader, no matter how well-intentioned the concept behind the article.

There is very little –or perhaps no point at all!- in writing something that, no matter how worthy the concept, completely loses the majority of the readers. I have come to understand that it is far, far too easy to lose readers than it is to catch their attention.

It is said that the first sentence is the important one. Catch them with that and you have them to the end of the article.

Having examined my work, my article, from the perspective of a reader (or at least as close to the perspective of a reader as it is possible for the author of the article to get) I finds that the first sentence is important. But then, so is the next one, and the next one and… well, I am sure you get the picture.

Whilst it is true that it  is easy not to attract the attention of a reader with a poor opening sentence it is even easier to lose them through a poorly structured body of an article. Some of the subsequent paragraphs, if you will.

I have struggled with this article, I have to admit. I realise that there are several different ways to see an article. From the point of view of the author, the editor and the reader.